Debunk: Can we really claim to be able to make music with plants?
Stéphane Marty, from the YouTube channel "Deus ex silicium," delved into sonification devices to better understand this "plant music" phenomenon.
Highly pragmatic, he explains the equipment and its measurement potential, as well as the nuances needed to understand how to make music WITH plants, as plants cannot naturally produce music.
It is essential to name and emphasize this difference because plants speak in molecules, not musical notes.
With Naturasounds, we are pioneers in this research to open up to this symphony of life, to re-evaluate the universal message that plants bring us. For almost 6 years, we have been conducting Research and Development to produce precise measuring devices that honor the message plants offer us, because it is a biochemical message. Plants understand the vibration of molecules but have no concept of music at all.
Like birdsong, plant song uses natural scale relationships, with harmonies found only in this type of song.
The work of Sir Jagadish Chandra Bose and Cleve Backster guides us towards "inter-species bio-communication" and not towards a form of art that is not universal but conceived solely by humans to have another type of sound communication. Music being the art of sounds, we note that no other living organism uses it in the tempered manner that Pythagoras intended. Moreover, there is no universal harmony as Pythagoras proposed, and institutions like the Max Planck Institute or prestigious universities like Cambridge and Princeton explain this.
https://www.sciencesetavenir.fr/fondamental/mathematiques/et-si-pythagore-avait-tort-sur-ce-qu-est-de-la-bonne-musique_177038
When one is aware that a plant has its own form of intelligence and consciousness, it is impossible to claim that a plant would make music like a human; its language is much richer and more complex, hence the term "inter-species bio-communication."
Therefore, the term "plant music" is either used to refer to Italian devices because it is a registered trademark, or to interpret an action that plants produce to sell you these devices. In any case, we will speak of anthropomorphism or intellectual scam if people trivialize and insist on this term to make it seem as if plants naturally make music.
If we are respectful of life and plant intelligence, we will speak in terms of "inter-species bio-communication."
Thanks to Stéphane Marty for debunking and setting the record straight.
"Because honestly, at 638 euros, they really take people for fools"
And when I think that these same people wanted us to release a device at over 2000 euros, it's clear that it's not an openness to inter-species bio-communication that interests them, but rather the potential profit from reselling equipment they didn't even design themselves... ah, these tricksters, they're everywhere and try to pass themselves off as saviors...
So, beware of "plant music initiation"; it's a big scam, and as debunked here, opt for devices like Plantsplay, Plantwave, or the Pocket Scion that we offer with training on our site. Even with the training, this pack is well below the very expensive prices of that brand.
https://natura-sounds.com/products/pack-pocket-scion-formation
Or if you are a DIY enthusiast, you can produce your own device, keeping in mind that plants speak in molecules and not sound frequencies. They speak electrophysiology and tell us about life with harmony, allowing us to see that to be healthy, we must find a healthy balance between body and mind. This balance reveals itself in sounds because where there is harmony, there is peace, and the organism will function optimally.
This is why, since time immemorial, some humans have spoken to plants and animals to preserve the harmony of life that vibrates between organisms.
This allows us to relearn and understand how a whole functions to create homeostasis.